Influences upon Gothic architecture

The Gothic style of architecture was strongly influenced by the Romanesque architecture which preceded it. Why the Gothic style emerged from Romanesque, and what the key influences on its development were, is a difficult problem for which there is a lack of concrete evidence because medieval Gothic architecture was not accompanied by contemporary written theory, in contrast to the 'Renaissance' and its treatises. ^{[1] [2]} A number of contrasting theories on the origins of Gothic have been advanced: for example, that Gothic emerged organically as a 'rationalist' answer to structural challenges; ^[3] that Gothic was informed by the methods of medieval Scholastic philosophy; ^[4] that Gothic was an attempt to imitate heaven and the light referred to in various Biblical passages such as Revelation; ^[5] that Gothic was 'medieval modernism' deliberately rejecting the 'historicist' forms of classical architecture. ^[6] Beyond specific theories, the style was also shaped by the specific geographical, political, religious and cultural context of Europe in the 12th century onwards (the 'first' Gothic building is considered to have been St Denis, in France in the 1140s by scholarly consensus ^[7] ).

Cathedrals in their cityscapes

Chartres Cathedral, France

Lincoln Cathedral, England

Florence Cathedral, Italy ^{[lower-alpha 1]}

Prague Cathedral, Bohemia ^{[lower-alpha 2]}

Albi Cathedral, France

Freiburg Minster, Germany

Political

At the end of the 12th century, Europe was divided into a multitude of city states and kingdoms. The area encompassing modern Germany, southern Denmark, the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg, Switzerland, Austria, Czech Republic and much of northern Italy (excluding Venice and Papal States) was nominally part of the Holy Roman Empire, but local rulers exercised considerable autonomy. France, Denmark, Poland, Hungary, Portugal, Scotland, Castile, Aragon, Navarre, and Cyprus were independent kingdoms, as was the Angevin Empire, whose Plantagenet kings ruled England and large domains in what was to become modern France. ^{[8] [ page needed ]} Norway came under the influence of England, while the other Scandinavian countries and Poland were influenced by trading contacts with the Hanseatic League. Swabian kings brought the Gothic tradition from Germany to Southern Italy, part of the Norman Kingdom of Sicily, while after the First Crusade the Lusignan kings introduced French Gothic architecture to Cyprus and the Kingdom of Jerusalem.^{[ citation needed ]}

Throughout Europe at this time there was a rapid growth in trade and an associated growth in towns. ^{[9] [ page needed ] [10] [ page needed ]} Germany and the Lowlands had large flourishing towns that grew in comparative peace, in trade and competition with each other, or united for mutual weal, as in the Hanseatic League. Civic building was of great importance to these towns as a sign of wealth and pride. England and France remained largely feudal and produced grand domestic architecture for their kings, dukes and bishops, rather than grand town halls for their burghers.^{[ citation needed ]}

Religious

The Roman Catholic Church prevailed across Western Europe at this time, influencing not only faith but also wealth and power. Bishops were appointed by the feudal lords (kings, dukes and other landowners) and they often ruled as virtual princes over large estates. The early mediaeval periods had seen a rapid growth in monasticism, with several different orders being prevalent and spreading their influence widely. Foremost were the Benedictines whose great abbey churches vastly outnumbered any others in France, Normandy and England.^{[ citation needed ]} A part of their influence was that towns developed around them and they became centres of culture, learning and commerce.^{[ citation needed ]} They were the builders of the Abbey of Saint-Denis, and Abbey of Saint-Remi in France.^{[ citation needed ]} Later Benedictine projects (constructions and renovations) include Rouen's Abbey of Saint-Ouen, the Abbey La Chaise-Dieu, and the choir of Mont Saint-Michel in France. English examples are Westminster Abbey, originally built as a Benedictine order monastic church; and the reconstruction of the Benedictine church at Canterbury.^{[ citation needed ]}

The Cluniac and Cistercian Orders were prevalent in France, the great monastery at Cluny having established a formula for a well planned monastic site which was then to influence all subsequent monastic building for many centuries. ^{[9] [ page needed ] [10] [ page needed ]} The Cistercians spread the style as far east and south as Poland and Hungary. ^[11] Smaller orders such as the Carthusians and Premonstratensians also built some 200 churches, usually near cities. ^[12]

In the 13th century Francis of Assisi established the Franciscans, or so-called "Grey Friars", a mendicant order. Saint Dominic founded the mendicant Dominicans, in Toulouse and Bologna, were particularly influential in the building of Italy's Gothic churches. ^{[9] [ page needed ] [10] [ page needed ]}

The Teutonic Order, a military order, spread Gothic art into Pomerania, East Prussia, and the Baltic region. ^[13]

Monastic churches

Abbey of Saint-Ouen, Rouen (1318–1537)

Bath Abbey, Bath, (present appearance 1501–)

Abbey of Saint-Remi, Reims (1170–80)

Batalha Monastery, Portugal (1386–1517)

Geographic

From the 10th to the 13th century, Romanesque architecture had become a pan-European style and manner of construction, affecting buildings in countries as far apart as Ireland, Croatia, Sweden and Sicily. The same wide geographic area was then affected by the development of Gothic architecture, but the acceptance of the Gothic style and methods of construction differed from place to place, as did the expressions of Gothic taste. The proximity of some regions meant that modern country borders do not define divisions of style. ^{[9] [ page needed ]} On the other hand, some regions such as England and Spain produced defining characteristics rarely seen elsewhere, except where they have been carried by itinerant craftsmen, or the transfer of bishops.^{[ citation needed ]} Regional differences that are apparent in the churches of the Romanesque period often become even more apparent in the Gothic. ^{[10] [ page needed ]}

The local availability of materials affected both construction and style. In France, limestone was readily available in several grades, the very fine white limestone of Caen being favoured for sculptural decoration.^{[ citation needed ]} England had coarse limestone and red sandstone as well as dark green Purbeck marble which was often used for architectural features.^{[ citation needed ]}

In Northern Germany, Netherlands, northern Poland, Denmark, and the Baltic countries local building stone was unavailable but there was a strong tradition of building in brick. The resultant style, Brick Gothic, is called "Backsteingotik" in Germany and Scandinavia and is associated with the Hanseatic League.^{[ citation needed ]} In Italy, stone was used for fortifications, but brick was preferred for other buildings. Because of the extensive and varied deposits of marble, many buildings were faced in marble, or were left with undecorated façade so that this might be achieved at a later date.^{[ citation needed ]}

The availability of timber also influenced the style of architecture, with timber buildings prevailing in Scandinavia.^{[ citation needed ]} Availability of timber affected methods of roof construction across Europe. It is thought that the magnificent hammer-beam roofs of England were devised as a direct response to the lack of long straight seasoned timber by the end of the mediaeval period, when forests had been decimated not only for the construction of vast roofs but also for ship building. ^{[9] [ page needed ] [14] [ page needed ]}

Romanesque tradition

Gothic architecture grew out of the previous architectural genre, Romanesque. For the most part, there was not a clean break, as there was to be later in Renaissance Florence with the revival of the Classical style in the early 15th century.^{[ citation needed ]}

By the 12th century, builders throughout Europe developed Romanesque architectural styles (termed Norman architecture in England because of its association with the Norman Conquest). ^[15] Scholars have focused on categories of Romanesque/Norman building, including the cathedral church, the parish church, the abbey church, the monastery, the castle, the palace, the great hall, the gatehouse, the civic building, the warehouse, and others. ^[16]

Many architectural features that are associated with Gothic architecture had been developed and used by the architects of Romanesque buildings, particularly in the building of cathedrals and abbey churches. These include ribbed vaults, buttresses, clustered columns, ambulatories, wheel windows, spires, stained glass windows, and richly carved door tympana. These were already features of ecclesiastical architecture before the development of the Gothic style, and all were to develop in increasingly elaborate ways. ^[17]

Delal Bridge, Iraq

It was principally the development of the pointed arch which brought about the change that separates Gothic from Romanesque.^{[ citation needed ]} This technological change broke the tradition of massive masonry and solid walls penetrated by small openings, replacing it with a style where light appears to triumph over substance.^{[ citation needed ]} With its use came the development of many other architectural devices, previously put to the test in scattered buildings and then called into service to meet the structural, aesthetic and ideological needs of the new style. These include the flying buttresses, pinnacles and traceried windows. ^[9]

Church at Qasr ibn Wardan, Syria (564)

Arches at ar-Raqqa, Syria

Monreale Cathedral, Sicily (1174)

Eastern Christian, Sasanian, and Islamic Architecture

The pointed arch, one of the defining attributes of Gothic, appears in Late Roman Byzantine architecture and the Sasanian architecture of Iran during late antiquity, although the form had been used earlier, as in the possibly 1st century AD Temple of Bel, Dura Europos in Roman Mesopotamia. ^[18] In the Roman context it occurred in church buildings in Syria and occasional secular structures, like the Karamagara Bridge in modern Turkey. In Sassanid architecture parabolic and pointed arches were employed in both palace and sacred construction. ^[19] A very slightly pointed arch built in 549 exists in the apse of the Basilica of Sant'Apollinare in Classe in Ravenna, and slightly more pointed example from a church, built 564 at Qasr Ibn Wardan in Roman Syria. ^[20] Pointed arches' development may have been influenced by the elliptical and parabolic arches frequently employed in Sasanian buildings using pitched brick vaulting, which obviated any need for wooden centring and which had for millennia been used in Mesopotamia and Syria. ^[21] The oldest pointed arches in Islamic architecture are in the Dome of the Rock, completed in 691/2, while some others appear in the Great Mosque of Damascus, begun in 705. ^[22] The Umayyads were responsible for the oldest significantly pointed arches in medieval western Europe, employing them alongside horseshoe arches in the Great Mosque of Cordoba, built from 785 and repeatedly extended. ^[23] The Abbasid palace at al-Ukhaidir employed pointed arches in 778 as a dominant theme both structural and decorative throughout the façades and vaults of the complex, while the tomb of al-Muntasir, built 862, employed a dome with a pointed arch profile. Abbasid Samarra had many pointed arches, notably its surviving Bab al-ʿAmma (monumental triple gateway). By the 9th century the pointed arch was used in Egypt and North Africa: in the Nilometer at Fustat in 861, the 876 Mosque of Ibn Tulun in Cairo, and the 870s Great Mosque of Kairouan. Through the 8th and 9th centuries, the pointed arch was employed as standard in secular buildings in architecture throughout the Islamic world. ^[24] The 10th century Aljafería at Zaragoza displays numerous forms of arch, including many pointed arches decorated and elaborated to a level of design sophistication not seen in Gothic architecture for a further two centuries. ^[23]

Increasing military and cultural contacts with the Muslim world, including the Norman conquest of Islamic Sicily between 1060 and 1090, the Crusades, beginning 1096, and the Islamic presence in Spain, may have influenced medieval Europe's adoption of the pointed arch, although this hypothesis remains controversial. ^[25] The structural advantages of pointed arches seems first to have been realised in a medieval Latin Christian context at the abbey church known as Cluny III at Cluny Abbey. ^[26] Begun by abbot Hugh of Cluny in 1089, the great Romanesque church of Cluny III was the largest church in the west when completed in 1130. ^[27] Kenneth John Conant, who excavated the site of the church's ruins, argued that the architectural innovations of Cluny III were inspired by the Islamic architecture of Sicily via Monte Cassino. ^[26] The Abbey of Monte Cassino was the foundational community of the Benedictine Order and lay within the Norman Kingdom of Sicily, which at that time also had Arabic-speaking Muslim communities^{[ citation needed ]}. The rib vault with pointed arches was used at Lessay Abbey in Normandy in 1098, ^[28] , Cefalù Cathedral in Sicily and at Durham Cathedral in England at about the same time. ^[29] In those parts of the Western Mediterranean subject to Islamic control or influence, rich regional variants arose, fusing Romanesque, Byzantine and later Gothic traditions with Islamic decorative forms, as seen, for example, in Monreale and Cefalù Cathedrals, the Alcázar of Seville, and Teruel Cathedral. ^{[30] [31]}

Notes

1. While the engineering and construction of the dome of Florence Cathedral by Brunelleschi is often cited as one of the first works of the Renaissance, the octagonal plan, ribs and pointed silhouette were already determined in the 14th century.
2. The Gothic south tower is surmounted by a Baroque spire.

Citations

1. Trachtenberg, Marvin (January 2000). "Suger's Miracles, Branner's Bourges: Reflections on "Gothic Architecture" as Medieval Modernism". Gesta. 39 (2): 194. doi:10.2307/767145. ISSN   0016-920X. JSTOR   767145. S2CID   191408625.
2. Robinson, Alfie (2023-02-22). "'Like, or Better': Building Contracts and Late-Medieval Perceptions of Quality in Architecture". Journal of the British Archaeological Association: 3. doi:10.1080/00681288.2023.2168897. ISSN   0068-1288. S2CID   257147542.
3. Rudolph, Conrad (2019-04-15), Rudolph, Conrad (ed.), "Introduction: A Sense of Loss: An Overview of the Historiography of Romanesque and Gothic Art", A Companion to Medieval Art (1 ed.), Wiley, p. 25, doi:10.1002/9781119077756.ch1, ISBN   978-1-119-07772-5, S2CID   240902117 , retrieved 2023-05-07
4. Panofsky, Erwin (1951). Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism. Archabbey Press.
5. Simson, Otto Georg von (2020-06-16). The Gothic Cathedral: Origins of Gothic Architecture and the Medieval Concept of Order - Expanded Edition. Princeton University Press. p. 8. ISBN   978-0-691-21403-0.
6. Trachtenberg, Marvin (2000). "Suger's Miracles, Branner's Bourges: Reflections on "Gothic Architecture" as Medieval Modernism". Gesta. 39 (2): 184. doi:10.2307/767145. ISSN   0016-920X. JSTOR   767145. S2CID   191408625.
7. Rudolph, Conrad (2019-04-15), Rudolph, Conrad (ed.), "Introduction: A Sense of Loss: An Overview of the Historiography of Romanesque and Gothic Art", A Companion to Medieval Art (1 ed.), Wiley, p. 24, doi:10.1002/9781119077756.ch1, ISBN   978-1-119-07772-5, S2CID   240902117 , retrieved 2023-05-07
8. "L'art Gothique", section: "L'architecture Gothique en Angleterre" by Ute Engel: L'Angleterre fut l'une des premieres régions à adopter, dans la deuxième moitié du XIIeme siècle, la nouvelle architecture gothique née en France. Les relations historiques entre les deux pays jouèrent un rôle prépondérant: en 1154, Henri II (1154–1189), de la dynastie Française des Plantagenêt, accéda au thrône d'Angleterre." (England was one of the first regions to adopt, during the first half of the 12th century, the new Gothic architecture born in France. Historic relationships between the two countries played a determining role: in 1154, Henry II (1154–1189) became the first of the Anjou Plantagenet kings to ascend to the throne of England). ^{[ page needed ]}
9. Banister Fletcher, A History of Architecture on the Comparative Method.^{[ page needed ]}
10. John Harvey, The Gothic World
11. Grodecki 1977, p. 28.
12. Grodecki 1977, pp. 29–30.
13. Grodecki 1977, p. 30.
14. Alec Clifton-Taylor, The Cathedrals of England ^{[ page needed ]}
15. Robert Liddiard, Anglo-Norman Castles (Woodbridge, Suffolk: Boydell, 2003). ISBN   0851159044; and Kenneth John Conant, Carolingian and Romanesque Architecture, 800 to 1200 (NY: Penguin, 1959; reprint, New Haven CT: Yale University Press, 1993). ISBN   0300052987
16. Maximilian Sternberg, Cistercian Architecture and Medieval Society (Leiden: Brill, 2013), 132–50. ISBN   9004251812; Eric Fernie, The Architecture of Norman England (Oxford University Press, 2000), 4–20 and 50. ISBN   0199250812; and Ann Williams, "A bell-house and a burh-geat: lordly residences in England before the Norman Conquest", Medieval Knighthood 4 (1992): 221–40.
17. Nikolaus Pevsner, An Outline of European Architecture. ^{[ page needed ]}
18. Draper 2005, p. 1–20.
19. Warren, John (1991). "Creswell's Use of the Theory of Dating by the Acuteness of the Pointed Arches in Early Muslim Architecture". Muqarnas. 8. BRILL: 59–65, 61–63. doi:10.2307/1523154. JSTOR   1523154.
20. Draper 2005, p. 3–4.
21. Draper 2005, p. 4.
22. Draper 2005, p. 8.
23. Draper 2005, p. 12.
24. Draper 2005, p. 15.
25. Scott 2003, p. 113.
26. Draper 2005, p. 17–18.
27. "Cluny Abbey (article) | Romanesque". Khan Academy. Retrieved 2020-05-07.
28. François Salet, « L'église abbatiale de Lessay », Bulletin monumental, vol. 1117, no 1, 1959, p. 56-59
29. "The notable exception is Durham Cathedral, the nave and choir of which (c. 1104) are supported by the first known examples of pointed ribbed vaults." Norman style at the Encyclopædia Britannica
30. Le genie architectural des Normands a su s'adapter aux lieux en prenant ce qu'il y a de meilleur dans le savoir-faire des batisseurs arabes et byzantins", Les Normands en Sicile, pp.14, 53–57.
31. Harvey, L. P. (1992). "Islamic Spain, 1250 to 1500". Chicago : University of Chicago Press. ISBN   0-226-31960-1; Boswell, John (1978). Royal Treasure: Muslim Communities Under the Crown of Aragon in the Fourteenth Century. Yale University Press. ISBN   0-300-02090-2.

Bibliography

• Bechmann, Roland (2017). Les Racines des Cathédrales (in French). Payot. ISBN   978-2-228-90651-7.
• Burton, Janet B.; Kerr, Julie (2011). The Cistercians in the Middle Ages. Monastic orders. Vol. 4 (Illustrated ed.). Boydell Press. ISBN   9781843836674.
• Bony, Jean (1983). French Gothic Architecture of the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries. University of California Press. ISBN   978-0-520-02831-9.
• Chastel, André (2000). L'Art Français Pré-Moyen Âge Moyen Âge (in French). Paris: Flammarion. ISBN   2-08-012298-3.
• Ching, Francis D.K. (2012). A Visual Dictionary of Architecture (2nd ed.). John Wiley & Sons, Inc. ISBN   978-0-470-64885-8.
• Clark, W. W.; King, R. (1983). Laon Cathedral, Architecture. Courtauld Institute Illustration Archives. 1. London: Harvey Miller Publishers. ISBN   9780905203553.
• Der Manuelian, Lucy (2001). "Ani: The Fabled Capital of Armenia". In Cowe, S. Peter (ed.). Ani: World Architectural Heritage of a Medieval Armenian Capital. Leuven Sterling. ISBN   978-90-429-1038-6.
• Draper, Peter (2005). "Islam and the West: The Early Use of the Pointed Arch Revisited". Architectural History. 5: 1–20. doi:10.1017/S0066622X00003701. ISSN   0066-622X. JSTOR   40033831. S2CID   194947480.
• Ducher, Robert (1988). Caractéristique des Styles (in French). Flammarion. ISBN   978-2-08-011539-3.
• Fiske, Kimball (1943). The Creation of the Rococo. Philadelphia Museum of Art.
• Fletcher, Banister (2001). A History of Architecture on the Comparative Method. Elsevier Science & Technology. ISBN   978-0-7506-2267-7.
• Garsoïan, Nina G. (2015). "Sirarpie Der Nersessian (1896–1989)". In Damico, Helen (ed.). Medieval Scholarship: Biographical Studies on the Formation of a Discipline: Religion and Art. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-317-77636-9.
• Giese, Francine; Pawlak, Anna; Thome, Markus (2018). Tomb – Memory – Space: Concepts of Representation in Premodern Christian and Islamic Art (in German). Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co KG. ISBN   9783110517347.
• Grodecki, Louis (1977). Nervi, Luigi (ed.). Gothic Architecture. In collaboration with Anne Prache and Roland Recht, translated from French by I. Mark Paris. Abrams Books. ISBN   978-0-8109-1008-9.
• Harvey, John (1950). The Gothic World, 1100–1600. Batsford. ISBN   978-0-00-255228-8.
• Harvey, John (1974). Châteaux et Cathédrals-L'Art des Batisseurs, L'Encyclopedie de la Civilisation (in French). London: Thames and Hudson.
• Hughes, William; Punter, David; Smith, Andrew (2015). The Encyclopedia of the Gothic. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN   9781119210412.
• Jones, Colin (1999). The Cambridge Illustrated History of France. Cambridge University Press. ISBN   978-0-521-66992-4.
• Lang, David Marshall (1980). Armenia: Cradle of Civilization. Allen & Unwin.
• Martin, G. H.; Highfield, J. R. L. (1997). A history of Merton College, Oxford. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN   0-19-920183-8.
• Martindale, Andrew (1993). Gothic Art. Thames and Hudson. ISBN   978-2-87811-058-6.
• McNamara, Denis (2017). Comprendre l'Art des Églises (in French). Larousse. ISBN   978-2-03-589952-1.
• Mignon, Olivier (2017). Architecture du Patrimoine Française - Abbayes, Églises, Cathédrales et Châteaux (in French). Éditions Ouest-France. ISBN   978-27373-7611-5.
• Mignon, Olivier (2015). Architecture des Cathédrales Gothiques (in French). Éditions Ouest-France. ISBN   978-2-7373-6535-5.
• Mitchell, Ann (1968). Cathedrals of Europe. Great Buildings of the World. Hamlyn. ASIN   B0006C19ES.
• Moffat, Fazio & Wodehouse (2003). A World History of Architecture. Laurence King Publishing. ISBN   1-85669-353-8.
• Montagnon, Pierre (2016). La France des Clochers (in French). Editions Telemaque. ISBN   978-2-7533-0307-2.
• Oggins, R.O. (2000). Cathedrals. Friedman/Fairfax Publishers. ISBN   9781567993462 . Retrieved 6 October 2010.{{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
• Pevsner, Nikolaus (1964). An Outline of European Architecture. Pelican Books. ISBN   978-0-14-061613-2.
• Poisson, Georges; Poisson, Olivier (2014). Eugène Viollet-le-Duc (in French). Paris: Picard. ISBN   978-2-7084-0952-1.
• Raeburn, Michael (1980). "The Middle Ages". In Coldstream, Nicola (ed.). Architecture of the Western World. With a foreword by Sir Hugh Casson. Rizzoli International. ISBN   978-0-8478-0349-1.
• Renault, Christophe; Lazé, Christophe (2006). Les Styles de l'architecture et du mobilier (in French). Gisserot. ISBN   978-2-87747-465-8.
• Scott, Robert A. (2003). The Gothic enterprise: a guide to understanding the Medieval cathedral. University of California Press. ISBN   978-0-520-23177-1.
• Stewart, Cecil (1959). History of Architectural Development: Early Christian, Byzantine and Romanesque Architecture. Longman.
• Swaan, Wim (1988). The Gothic Cathedral. Omega Books. ISBN   978-0-907853-48-0.
• Rice, David Talbot (1972). The Appreciation of Byzantine Art. Oxford University Press.
• Texier, Simon (2012). Paris Panorama de l'architecture de l'Antiquité à nos jours (in French). Parigramme. ISBN   978-2-84096-667-8.
• Toman, Rolf (2007). Néoclassicisme et Romantisme. Ulmann. ISBN   978-3-8331-3557-6.
• Vasari, Giorgio (1907). Brown, Gerald Baldwin; Maclehose, Louisa (eds.). Vasari on Technique: Being the Introduction to the Three Arts of Design, Architecture, Sculpture and Painting, Prefixed to the Lives of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors and Architects. J. M. Dent & Co.
• Vasari, Giorgio (1991). The Lives of the Artists . Translated with an introduction and notes by J.C. and P. Bondanella. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-953719-8.
• Viollet-le-Duc, Eugène (1868). Dictionnaire raisonné de l'architecture française du XIe au XVIe siècle. Édition BANCE.
• Watkin, David (1986). A History of Western Architecture. Barrie and Jenkins. ISBN   0-7126-1279-3.
• Wenzler, Claude (2018). Les cathédrales gothiques: Un défi médiéval (in French). Éditions Ouest-France. ISBN   978-2-7373-7712-9.
• "Chartres Cathedral Royal Portal Sculpture". Chartres Cathedral. 2020. Retrieved 31 May 2020.