1934 California gubernatorial election

Last updated

1934 California gubernatorial election
Flag of California (1924-1953).png
  1930 November 6, 1934 1938  
  Governor Frank Merriam votes at a polling place, California, 1934-1939 (cropped).jpg Upton Sinclair, 1935.jpg Raymond Haight, 1930s.jpg
Nominee Frank Merriam Upton Sinclair Raymond L. Haight
Party Republican Democratic Progressive
Popular vote1,138,620879,537302,519
Percentage48.87%37.75%12.99%

1934 California gubernatorial election results map by county.svg
County results
Merriam:      30-40%     40–50%     50–60     60-70%     80-90%
Sinclair:      30-40%     40–50%
Haight:      30-40%

Governor before election

Frank Merriam
Republican

Elected Governor

Frank Merriam
Republican

The 1934 California gubernatorial election was held on November 6, 1934. Held in the midst of the Great Depression, the 1934 election was amongst the most controversial in the state's political history, pitting conservative Republican Frank Merriam against former Socialist Party member turned Democratic politician Upton Sinclair, author of The Jungle . A strong third party challenge came from Progressive Raymond L. Haight, a Los Angeles lawyer campaigning for the political center. Much of the campaign's emphasis was directed at Sinclair's EPIC movement, proposing interventionist reforms to cure the state's ailing economy. Merriam, who had recently assumed the governorship following the death of James Rolph, characterized Sinclair's proposal as a step towards communism.

Contents

Democratic primary

Candidates

Results

Sinclair won the Democratic nomination in what was considered a political upset. [1]

Primary results by county
.mw-parser-output .legend{page-break-inside:avoid;break-inside:avoid-column}.mw-parser-output .legend-color{display:inline-block;min-width:1.25em;height:1.25em;line-height:1.25;margin:1px 0;text-align:center;border:1px solid black;background-color:transparent;color:black}.mw-parser-output .legend-text{}
Sinclair
Sinclair--70-80%
Sinclair--60-70%
Sinclair--50-60%
Sinclair--40-50%
Sinclair--30-40%
Creel
Creel--60-70%
Creel--50-60%
Creel--40-50%
Creel--30-40% 1934 California gubernatorial election Democratic primary results map by county.svg
Primary results by county
  Sinclair
  •   Sinclair—70-80%
  •   Sinclair—60-70%
  •   Sinclair—50-60%
  •   Sinclair—40-50%
  •   Sinclair—30-40%
  Creel
  •   Creel—60–70%
  •   Creel—50-60%
  •   Creel—40–50%
  •   Creel—30-40%
Democratic primary results [2]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Upton Sinclair 436,220 51.68%
Democratic George Creel 288,10634.13%
Democratic Justus S. Wardell 48,9655.80%
Democratic Milton K. Young41,6094.93%
Democratic James E. Waddell12,5151.48%
Democratic Z. T. Malaby4,4760.53%
Democratic Forest Dowey4,2600.50%
Democratic W. J. McNichols3,6160.43%
Democratic William H. Evans2,4330.29%
Democratic Frank F. Merriam (write-in)1,0350.12%
Democratic Raymond L. Haight (write-in)8820.10%
Total votes844,117 100.00%

Republican primary

Candidates

Results

Republican primary results [2]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Frank F. Merriam (incumbent) 346,329 41.94%
Republican C. C. Young 231,43128.03%
Republican John R. Quinn 153,41218.58%
Republican Raymond L. Haight 84,97710.29%
Republican Upton Sinclair (write-in)9,6511.17%
Total votes825,800 100.00%

Minor party primaries

Socialist

Socialist primary results [2]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Socialist Milen C. Dempster 2,521 100.00%
Total votes2,521 100.00%

Commonwealth

Commonwealth primary results [2]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Commonwealth Raymond L. Haight 2,421100.00%
Total votes2,421 100.00%

Progressive

Progressive primary results [2]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Progressive Raymond L. Haight 1,344 100.00%
Total votes1,344 100.00%

Prohibition

Prohibition primary results [2]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Prohibition Frank F. Merriam (write-in) [lower-alpha 1] 96376.43%
Prohibition Upton Sinclair (write-in)29723.57%
Total votes1,260 100.00%

Communist

Communist primary results [2]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Communist Sam Darcy 1,072 100.00%
Total votes1,072 100.00%

General election

Campaign

Negative campaigning funded by the film industry was used against Sinclair to favor the Merriam campaign, as depicted in the 2020 American biographical drama film Mank . [3] Hollywood studio bosses unanimously opposed Sinclair and their involvement in the campaign has been described as Hollywood's first intervention in electoral politics. [4] They pressured their employees to assist and vote for Merriam's campaign, and made false propaganda films attacking Sinclair, giving him no opportunity to respond. [5] Joseph M. Schenck threatened to move Twentieth Century Fox to Florida should Sinclair be elected. [6]

Louis B. Mayer's MGM and other film studios deducted a days pay from their employees to raise an anti-Sinclair fund that amounted to $500,000. Irving Thalberg was to lead MGM's anti-Sinclair campaign and the studio recruited Carey Wilson to create a series of anti-Sinclair propaganda films. These films, directed by Felix E. Feist, included fake newsreels of Sinclair supporters who were portrayed as bums and criminals. They were shown in Californian movie theaters, with one episode featuring hired actors as Sinclair supporters speaking with foreign accents. [7]

Big corporations in California were strongly opposed to Sinclair. Both Standard Oil of California and Pacific Mutual sent out a letter to their stockholders encouraging them to oppose Sinclair. Various corporations created front organisations to oppose his campaign, for instance the California Real Estate Association formed the 'Merriam for Governor Committee'. [8]

Upton Sinclair later stated that there was a "campaign of lying" against him during the campaign which was "ordered by the biggest businessmen in California and paid for with millions of dollars" that was carried out by newspapers, politicians, advertisers, and the film industry. [9] One survey of over 500 Californian newspapers found that over 90% supported Merriam, 5% supported Raymond Haight and the rest made no endorsement. The only newspaper surveyed which endorsed Sinclair was his own outlet Epic News. [6]

However, Sinclair did have support from some public figures. For instance the 'Author's League for Sinclair' was founded by Dorothy Thompson and Gene Fowler. Progressives like Charlie Chaplin, [10] Dorothy Parker, Donald Ogden Stewart, Lillian Hellman and Groucho Marx were also Sinclair supporters. [4]

Candidates

Results

1934 California gubernatorial election [11]
PartyCandidateVotes%±%
Republican Frank F. Merriam (incumbent) 1,138,620 48.87% −23.28%
Democratic Upton Sinclair 879,53737.75%+13.64%
Progressive Raymond L. Haight 302,51912.99%+12.99%
Communist Sam Darcy 5,8260.25%+0.25%
Socialist Milen C. Dempster2,9470.13%−3.52%
Scattering2730.01%
Majority259,08311.12%
Total votes2,329,458 100.00%
Republican hold Swing -36.93%

Results by county

CountyFrank F. Merriam
Republican
Upton Sinclair
Democratic
Raymond L. Haight
Progressive
Sam Darcy
Communist
Milen C. Dempster
Socialist
Scattering
Write-in
MarginTotal votes cast [11]
# %# %# %# %# %# %# %
Alameda 102,32852.68%73,23337.70%17,7589.14%5810.30%2910.15%410.02%29,09514.98%194,232
Alpine 15887.29%137.18%105.52%00.00%00.00%00.00%14580.11%181
Amador 1,94652.00%98126.22%80221.43%90.24%40.11%00.00%96525.79%3,742
Butte 8,04147.82%5,93235.28%2,79516.62%290.17%180.11%00.00%2,10912.54%16,815
Calaveras 1,52445.83%1,23237.05%55316.63%80.24%50.15%30.09%2928.78%3,325
Colusa 2,58455.70%86118.56%1,17925.41%80.17%70.15%00.00%1,405 [lower-alpha 2] 30.29%4,639
Contra Costa 15,54045.52%15,59145.67%2,8948.48%800.23%280.08%70.02%-51-0.15%34,140
Del Norte 1,22149.39%1,10644.74%1295.22%40.16%120.49%00.00%1154.65%2,472
El Dorado 1,74433.37%1,68132.17%1,76633.79%230.44%120.23%00.00%-22-0.42%5,226
Fresno 15,33830.46%15,50930.80%19,29638.33%1010.20%1010.20%20.00%-3,787 [lower-alpha 3] -7.53%50,347
Glenn 2,34246.00%1,45628.60%1,28625.26%20.04%50.10%00.00%88617.40%5,091
Humboldt 9,17950.95%6,44835.79%2,27112.61%790.44%380.21%00.00%2,73115.16%18,015
Imperial 7,25352.01%5,63740.42%1,0017.18%170.12%380.27%00.00%1,61611.59%13,946
Inyo 1,51457.39%87733.24%2328.79%110.42%40.15%00.00%63724.15%2,638
Kern 14,79848.59%11,34837.26%4,19713.78%490.16%600.20%20.01%3.45011.33%30,454
Kings 3,63341.18%2,32626.37%2,84832.28%50.06%90.10%10.01%785 [lower-alpha 2] 8.90%8,822
Lake 2,31756.54%1,33832.65%43310.57%10.02%90.22%00.00%97923.89%4,098
Lassen 1,69733.09%2,02339.44%1,38226.94%60.12%210.41%00.00%-326-6.36%5,129
Los Angeles 457,75547.45%405,33142.02%98,34810.20%2,2380.23%8220.09%1420.01%52,4245.43%964,636
Madera 2,20432.84%2,44136.37%2,04330.44%160.24%80.12%00.00%-237-3.53%6,712
Marin 9,75654.50%6,49436.28%1,5558.69%430.24%490.27%50.03%3,26218.22%17,902
Mariposa 1,08946.80%86537.17%35415.21%70.30%120.52%00.00%2249.63%2,327
Mendocino 6,17862.87%2,76328.12%7948.08%680.69%230.23%10.01%3,41534.75%9,827
Merced 4,12335.52%3,72732.10%3,72732.10%180.16%130.11%10.01%3963.41%11,609
Modoc 1,45249.39%83628.44%63721.67%50.17%100.34%00.00%61620.95%2,940
Mono 52063.11%23428.40%647.77%10.12%50.61%00.00%28634.71%824
Monterey 11,08361.53%5,58531.01%1,2857.13%400.22%160.09%40.02%5,49830.52%18,013
Napa 5,75058.96%2,80628.77%1,17512.05%110.11%110.11%00.00%2,94430.19%9,753
Nevada 3,16345.33%2,16531.03%1,60222.96%280.40%190.27%00.00%99814.30%6,977
Orange 27,09953.73%14,09227.94%9,14218.13%590.12%420.08%40.01%13,00725.79%50,438
Placer 3,33734.23%3,11331.93%3,27133.55%160.16%130.13%00.00%66 [lower-alpha 2] 0.68%9,750
Plumas 1,21336.64%1,22637.03%85825.91%20.06%120.36%00.00%-13-0.39%3,311
Riverside 19,89262.33%9,89631.01%2,0726.49%310.10%240.08%00.00%9,99631.32%31,915
Sacramento 19,36035.75%16,29130.09%18,31033.81%1330.25%510.09%30.01%1,050 [lower-alpha 2] 1.94%54,148
San Benito 2,93165.25%1,25127.85%2966.59%60.13%80.18%00.00%1,68037.40%4,492
San Bernardino 30,28556.76%19,15735.90%3,7747.07%800.15%570.11%60.01%11,12820.85%53,359
San Diego 44,42250.76%32,07336.65%10,75912.29%1850.21%690.08%00.00%12,34914.11%87,508
San Francisco 115,04750.91%87,85038.88%21,4999.51%1,1160.49%4330.19%320.01%27,19712.04%225,977
San Joaquin 17,61246.64%13,72036.33%6,25516.56%700.19%1040.28%00.00%3,89210.31%37,761
San Luis Obispo 6,42247.11%5,09337.36%2,06315.13%340.25%190.14%00.00%1,3299.75%13,631
San Mateo 18,44852.29%13,02236.91%3,66910.40%920.26%400.11%60.02%5,42615.38%35,277
Santa Barbara 14,42960.29%7,73532.32%1,7027.11%530.22%110.05%20.01%6,69427.97%23,932
Santa Clara 37,15660.06%19,28131.17%5,2158.43%1070.17%1000.16%20.00%17,87528.90%61,861
Santa Cruz 10,90563.17%5,15529.86%1,1196.48%740.43%80.05%30.02%5,75033.31%17,264
Shasta 3,28342.75%2,81936.71%1,54320.09%70.09%280.36%00.00%4646.04%7,680
Sierra 67645.19%47131.48%33922.66%20.13%70.47%10.07%20513.70%1,496
Siskiyou 4,20239.19%3,51432.77%2,95327.54%160.15%370.35%00.00%6886.42%10,722
Solano 6,72844.57%5,11233.87%3,20621.24%290.19%190.13%00.00%1,61610.71%15,094
Sonoma 15,32957.41%8,16430.58%3,07011.50%900.34%430.16%30.01%7,16526.84%26,699
Stanislaus 7,85334.46%6,26027.47%8,59237.70%180.08%640.28%10.00%-739-3.24%22,788
Sutter 2,87247.01%1,98032.41%1,24420.36%80.13%50.08%00.00%89214.60%6,109
Tehama 2,86544.34%1,81628.10%1,76327.28%70.11%110.17%00.00%1,04916.23%6,462
Trinity 88940.21%99344.91%30813.93%130.59%80.36%00.00%-104-4.70%2,211
Tulare 9,85037.46%6,86726.12%9,51236.18%460.17%180.07%10.00%338 [lower-alpha 2] 1.29%26,294
Tuolumne 1,58036.62%1,94044.96%78518.19%00.00%100.23%00.00%-360-8.34%4,315
Ventura 11,01554.07%6,56032.20%2,74013.45%290.14%260.13%00.00%4,45521.87%20,370
Yolo 4,08746.44%1,64618.70%3,04134.56%120.14%140.16%00.00%1,046 [lower-alpha 2] 11.89%8,800
Yuba 2,60349.81%1,60130.64%1,00319.19%30.06%160.31%00.00%1,00219.17%5,226
Total1,138,62048.87%879,53737.75%302,51912.99%5,8260.25%2,9470.13%2730.01%259,08311.12%2,329,722

Counties that flipped from Republican to Democratic

Counties that flipped from Republican to Progressive

Notes

  1. Was not listed under Prohibition in the general election
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Margin over Haight
  3. Margin over Sinclair

Related Research Articles

The New Deal coalition was an American political coalition that supported the Democratic Party beginning in 1932. The coalition is named after President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal programs, and the follow-up Democratic presidents. It was composed of voting blocs who supported them. The coalition included labor unions, blue-collar workers, big city machines, racial and religious minorities, white Southerners, and intellectuals. Besides voters the coalition included powerful interest groups: Democratic Party organizations in most states, city machines, labor unions, some third parties, universities, and foundations. It was largely opposed by the Republican Party, the business community, and rich Protestants. In creating his coalition, Roosevelt was at first eager to include liberal Republicans and some radical third parties, even if it meant downplaying the "Democratic" name. By the 1940s, the Republican and third-party allies had mostly been defeated. In 1948, the Democratic Party stood alone and survived the splits that created two splinter parties.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Upton Sinclair</span> American writer (1878–1968)

Upton Beall Sinclair Jr. was an American author, muckraker, and political activist, and the 1934 Democratic Party nominee for governor of California. He wrote nearly 100 books and other works in several genres. Sinclair's work was well known and popular in the first half of the 20th century, and he won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction in 1943.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hiram Johnson</span> California governor (1911–17) and senator (1917–45)

Hiram Warren Johnson was an American attorney and politician who served as the 23rd governor of California from 1911 to 1917. Johnson achieved national prominence in the early 20th century. He was elected in 1916 as the United States Senator from California, where he was re-elected to five terms and served until his death in 1945.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">End Poverty in California</span> Great Depression–era political platform

End Poverty in California (EPIC) was a political campaign started in 1934 by socialist writer Upton Sinclair. The movement formed the basis for Sinclair's campaign for Governor of California in 1934. The plan called for a massive public works program, sweeping tax reform, and guaranteed pensions. It gained major popular support, with thousands joining End Poverty Leagues across the state. EPIC never came to fruition due to Sinclair's defeat in the 1934 election, but is seen as an influence on New Deal programs enacted by President Franklin D. Roosevelt.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">C. C. Young</span> American politician

Clement Calhoun Young was an American educator and politician who was affiliated with the original Progressive Party and later the Republican Party. He was elected to five consecutive terms in the California State Assembly, serving from 1909 to 1919, then as the 28th lieutenant governor of California, holding that office from 1919 to 1927. In the 1926 general election, he was elected in a landslide victory as the 26th governor of California and served from 1927 to 1931. Young is considered to have been one of the last governors from the Progressive movement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Culbert Olson</span> American politician

Culbert Levy Olson was an American lawyer and politician. A Democratic Party member, Olson was involved in Utah and California politics and was elected as the 29th governor of California from 1939 to 1943. He was the first atheist governor of an American state.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sheridan Downey</span> American politician

Sheridan Downey was an American lawyer and a Democratic politician from Wyoming and California. In 1934, he ran for Lieutenant Governor of California as Upton Sinclair's running mate in the "End Poverty in California" campaign. In 1938 he was elected U.S. Senator from California, and he served from 1939 to 1950.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Friend Richardson</span> Governor of California (1865–1943)

Friend William Richardson was an American newspaper publisher and politician. A member of the Progressive Party and later the Republican Party, Richardson was elected as the California State Treasurer from 1915 to 1923, and shortly afterwards as the 25th governor of California from 1923 to 1927. Richardson's governorship marked a sharp reversal in policies from previous administrations, rolling back many of the Progressive reforms and state governmental agencies put in place by previous governors Hiram Johnson and William Stephens.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frank Merriam</span> 28th Governor of California

Frank Finley Merriam was an American Republican politician who served as the 28th governor of California from June 2, 1934, until January 2, 1939. Assuming the governorship at the height of the Great Depression following the death of Governor James Rolph, Merriam defeated Democratic nominee Upton Sinclair in the 1934 election. Merriam also served as the State Auditor of Iowa from 1900 to 1903, and served in both the Iowa and California state legislatures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">A. J. Barnes</span> American politician

A. J. Barnes was the first person to represent the 12th district of the Los Angeles City Council under the new charter in 1925. He served until 1927.

Clem Whitaker and Leone Baxter were a husband-and-wife team that started Campaigns, Inc., the first political consulting firm in the United States. Based in California, the firm worked on a variety of political issues, mostly for Republican Party candidates. They both supported conservative ideals.

The Progressive Party was a political party created as a vehicle for Robert M. La Follette, Sr. to run for president in the 1924 election. It did not run candidates for other offices, and it disappeared after the election. The party advocated progressive positions such as government ownership of railroads and electric utilities, cheap credit for farmers, the outlawing of child labor, stronger laws to help labor unions, more protection of civil liberties, an end to American imperialism in Latin America, and a referendum before any president could lead the nation into war.

Greg Mitchell is an American author and journalist. He has written twelve non-fiction books on United States politics and history of the 20th and 21st centuries. He has also written and directed three film documentaries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1970 California gubernatorial election</span>

The 1970 California gubernatorial election was held on November 3, 1970. The incumbent governor, Republican Ronald Reagan, won re-election over Democrat and Speaker of the Assembly Jesse Unruh. This would be the closest victory of Ronald Reagan's entire political career.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rob Wagner</span> American editor and publisher

Robert Leicester Wagner was the editor and publisher of Script, a weekly literary film magazine published in Beverly Hills, California, between 1929 and 1949.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1938 California gubernatorial election</span>

The 1938 California gubernatorial election was held on November 8, 1938. Culbert L. Olson defeated incumbent governor Frank F. Merriam to become the first Democrat elected Governor of California since James Budd in 1894. Merriam had angered the left and the right throughout his tenure as governor, leading a significant swing in favor of the Democratic party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1926 California gubernatorial election</span>

The 1926 California gubernatorial election was held on November 2, 1926. After ousting incumbent governor Friend William Richardson in the Republican primary, lieutenant governor C. C. Young defeated Justus S. Wardell in a landslide, sweeping every county in the state, the first time this had occurred in a gubernatorial election in California. Writer and activist Upton Sinclair ran on the Socialist ticket, the first of three consecutive gubernatorial elections in which he appeared on the ballot.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Raymond L. Haight</span> American lawyer

Raymond LeRoy Haight was an American lawyer and politician from California. Involved in the Republican and Commonwealth-Progressive parties, Haight ran as a third party candidate during the 1934 California gubernatorial election.

The California Progressive Party, also named California Bull Moose, was a political party that flourished from 1912 to 1944 and lasted through the 1960s.

<i>Mank</i> 2020 film by David Fincher

Mank is a 2020 American biographical drama film about screenwriter Herman J. Mankiewicz and his development of the screenplay for the 1941 film Citizen Kane. It was directed by David Fincher based on a screenplay written by his late father Jack Fincher and was produced by Ceán Chaffin, Douglas Urbanski, and Eric Roth. It stars Gary Oldman in the title role, alongside Amanda Seyfried, Lily Collins, Arliss Howard, Tom Pelphrey, Sam Troughton, Ferdinand Kingsley, Tuppence Middleton, Tom Burke, Joseph Cross, Jamie McShane, Toby Leonard Moore, Monika Gossman, and Charles Dance.

References

  1. Manchel, Frank (1990). Film Study An Analytical Bibliography · Volume 1. Fairleigh Dickinson University Press. p. 226.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 California Secretary of State. Statement of Vote at Primary Election held on August 28, 1934 in the State of California. Sacramento, California: State Printing Office. pp. 5–7. Retrieved July 19, 2024.
  3. Mitchell, Greg. "'Mank' and Politics: What Really Happened in 1934 California". New York Times, Dec 7, 2020.
  4. 1 2 Saverio, Giovacchini (2001). Hollywood Modernism Film and Politics in the Age of the New Deal. Temple University Press. p. 44.
  5. Cohen, Harvey G. (2015). "The Struggle to Fashion the NRA Code: The Triumph of Studio Power in 1933 Hollywood". Journal of American Studies. 50 (4): 1039–1066. doi:10.1017/S002187581500122X. ISSN   0021-8758. S2CID   147499614.
  6. 1 2 Singer, Donald L. (Winter 1974). "Upton Sinclair and the California Gubernatorial Campaign of 1934". Southern California Quarterly. 56 (4): 375–406. doi:10.2307/41171421. JSTOR   41171421.
  7. Critchlow, Donald T. (2013). When Hollywood Was Right How Movie Stars, Studio Moguls, and Big Business Remade American Politics. Cambridge University Press. pp. 26–27.
  8. American Fascism and the New Deal The Associated Farmers of California and the Pro-Industrial Movement. Lexington Books. 2013. pp. 58–9.
  9. Sinclair, Upton (2023). I, Candidate for Governor And How I Got Licked. University of California Press. p. 99.
  10. Maland, Charles J. (2021). Chaplin and American Culture The Evolution of a Star Image. Princeton University Press. pp. 135–6.
  11. 1 2 California Secretary of State. Statement of Vote at General Election held on November 6, 1934 in the State of California. Sacramento, California: State Printing Office. p. 5. Retrieved July 19, 2024.

Further reading